I figured I should save my review of the book until I saw the movie, which I did today. So now you get a very long post reviwing both. Anything that is too SPOILERY will be under a cut. I'm also trying to space the cuts so that if you click on one you won't have to see the others :)
The Prestige: The NovelI give this book a 10/10.
There is only one thing I didn't like about it and that was the very end, and only because it wasn't as resolved as I would have wished. However, in nearly 400 pages, having only one thing that I wasn't gung-ho about means it's a 10 for me anyway. Rarely am I this drawn into a plot or characters. Some people may not like the fact that the book has multiple narrators, but I found it very interesting. Figuring out who is reliable and what is generally going on was great fun. Priest also changes voices very well.
I will say, if you have seen the movie prior to reading the book, the suspense may not be as great and thus you may not feel as engaged as I did. But, I assure you the two are different enough that the book is still well worth the read even if the movie has already been viewed.
One of the things I really enjoyed about the book was that it deals smoothly with time-period language. I mean, it conveys the time period without being painfully annoying in vernacular. The use of certain phrases and words remind you of the time period without succumming to constant period language. That may annoy people who are staunch about period novels and might find the writing too modern, but I often find period novels like being stuck coninually in the eye with a needle and in turn, I very much like Priest's style.
There was even bits that reminded me of Pete Townshend.
( although those shall have to be put behind a cut )The Prestige: The MovieI give the movie a 8/10 (although if I hadn't read the book first it would probably be a 9).
It was a very good movie. All of the actors did great jobs, especially David Bowie who played Tesla with a mysterious air and a flawless accent. I was highly impressed by him, enough to get completely past his silly mustache. Alley was also very well played in the movie.
The overall look of the movie, the tones and shadows were done very well. I think it fit the (mostly dark) story perfectly and added to the notion of magic and rivalry.
I also liked the choice of narrator/his lines which introduced the story in the way I was expecting (that's said in a positive light, I was hoping they'd choose those lines).
I did however, not like the ending, for different reasons than why I did not like the book's ending of course. Though again, this was not enough to tarnish my liking for the film, and the reason I didn't like the ending may be influenced by my reading of the book. Oh, and before I get to the cut, Hugh Jackman is HOT.
( A bit of spoilers in what I would change... )The Book vs The MovieOne of the most interesting things about comparing the two is that Tesla's character was very different in each, and still probably my favorite character of both versions. I chalk this up to good description in the book and Bowie's acting skills in the movie. I do wish Tesla had a bigger part in both versions, but epecially the movie.
Although both are very good, I would side with the book over the movie. The biggest reasons being The Prestidigitators themselves (and the constant use of that word, which I adore btw). But that all belongs under a cut.
( The Prestidigitators )The End
( To comment without seeing spoilers lol click here )